Hello dear
Welcome to Sayle's Seafood
At Sayle's Seafood, nestled in the heart of Nantucket, customers are treated to a genuine seafood experience that feels like home. With an emphasis on freshness, the seafood is often brought in right before your eyes, ensuring unparalleled quality. The menu features mouthwatering highlights such as fried clams and savory clam chowder, both celebrated for their generous portions and delightful taste. This casual yet inviting seafood market caters to both dine-in guests and takeout lovers, making it a perfect stop for a relaxed meal by the harbor. The friendly staff enhance the experience, providing a warm and welcoming atmosphere.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Sayle's Seafood
Welcome to the delightful world of Sayle's Seafood, a true gem nestled in the heart of Nantucket at 99 Washington St Ext. This seafood haven is not just a market; it’s a culinary experience that captures the essence of coastal living.
Sayle's Seafood is renowned for its commitment to freshness and quality. Imagine biting into hot, tasty scallops, perfectly fried clams, and a comforting bowl of clam chowder that warms the soul. From friendly service provided by approachable staff to a laid-back ambiance that feels like an extension of your own grandma’s kitchen, every visit promises a personal touch. As one enthusiastic customer, Bruce Lamparelli, described, the seafood was complemented by “great fried clambellys” and “very good clam chowder,” which he savored while soaking in the beautiful view over the harbor.
What sets Sayle's apart is not just the delicious food but also the great value. David F attests to its affordability, making it one of the best dining options on the island. Despite its unpretentious nature, the quality of dishes like the fried oyster sandwich, steaming little neck clams, and generous portions of fish and chips leave a lasting impression. “It was the best fried seafood on the island,” declares Deb D, praising the immaculate handling of fresh ingredients that evoke memories of home-cooked meals.
When visiting Sayle's Seafood, you’ll find items that appeal to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters alike. The New England Lobster Bake, showcasing a perfectly steamed lobster alongside mussels and clams, offers a hearty experience for seafood lovers, while those craving something lighter can delight in the fresh swordfish, cut straight from the catch of the day. The small side orders that won't break the bank allow you to customize your meal to your own liking—a rare find on Nantucket.
- Hot and tasty scallops
- Delicious fried clams
- Rich and flavorful clam chowder
- Freshly prepared lobster and mussels
- Generous portions and budget-friendly prices
Sayle's Seafood stands out not just for its remarkable dishes but for an authentic atmosphere that invites you to enjoy your meal in a cozy, casual setting. Grab a seat on the porch, take in the breeze, and watch the world go by as you indulge in some of the freshest seafood available. You won’t be just visiting a restaurant; you’ll be making memories with every bite.
In short, when in Nantucket, a visit to Sayle's Seafood is a must. From their expertly fried seafood to the irresistible clam chowder, this establishment promises a feast that captures the heart of New England dining. Come hungry and leave happy!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Hot and tasty scallops, great fried clambellies, very good clam chowder and even the French fries were above average. Combined with a friendly and helpful counter Lady it was great. Too chilly to sit on the porch so we drove the 50 yards to the boat launch area and ate while looking out over the harbor. ”
“ Ordered a bunch of seafood for the family and they packaged it all up and we ate it at home. Lobsters were pre-cracked everything was delicious and we enjoyed it! ”
“ One of the best places I ate at on the island. This place is a seafood market and serves a lot of the restaurants. They also have a kitchen and I enjoyed some fantastic clam chowder as well as a fried oyster sandwich. These were really good. The sandwich came with a bag of cape cod chips. The soup came with Westminster oyster cracker. Also got some steamed little neck clams with butter. Prices are perhaps the cheapest on the island. (6 chowder and 19 fried clam sandwich, steamed clams were 12.95) Staff is friendly. There's about 3 tables outside on their deck with maybe 6-8 seats for those who wish to eat there. Wait time wasn't bad at all - maybe 10 minutes. It was not a far walk from the main drag. Would definitely come back again. ”
“ This place is such a gem. It is extremely causal so if you’re looking for something upscale this isn’t for you. But, if you don’t mind sitting outside and using plastic utensils, I highly suggest checking it out. The seafood is as fresh as it gets- we even saw a huge cooler being brought in while we sat outside and ate. Huge portions, very affordable (was shocked to find this on Nantucket), and the employees were lovely. Pictured are fish & chips, which comes with three large pieces of fish, a good amount of crispy fries, side of coleslaw, AND a cup of delicious clam chowder. Can’t wait to go back. ”
“ This is one of those places that is absolutely not high end, fancy, or anything like that. Don't get me wrong....it's by no means a dump. It is a really comfortable place that serves the absolute freshest seafood imaginable. It is pretty much the best fish market you could imagine, they also happen to sell some cooked seafood that you can takeout, or eat on the porch like I did. It's an old house style building, across from the water with a big front porch with granite top tables and plastic stackable lawn chairs. It's kind of like visiting someone's Grandma's house. IMMACULATE food handling, with delicious food like my Grandma would make ... better than any restaurant....only the best !!! No pretentious furnishings or trappings that end up inflating the bill....nope....nothing pretentious about this place. They do what they do, and they do it right. This is without doubt, the very best fried seafood on the island.....I can't believe I could get a small side order of whole belly fried clams for just 10. I don't know any place where you can buy an amount of fresh, sweet, whole clams for ten dollars. I really wanted their swordfish .... JUST WAIT until I tell you about that...but really, how often have you been vacillating over what to pick for dinner?This place has side orders ....but I mean side orders that are inexpensive enough, in two sizes, and the small size is small enough, that you aren't talking about the size and price of a whole other meal (just without sides.) I couldn't decide..I was dying for clams, and it's not easy to find good whole clams...but I also heard about their swordfish. By the way the swordfish dinner comes in two sizes...large and huge. They get it. They really get it. So, I ordered a small side of whole belly clams and a swordfish dinner. It was the best thing I could have done....oh my...back to the swordfish....they actually...get this... they actually CUT THE SWORDFISH STEAK from the fresh swordfish. Oh my ....oh my... really. It was a far cry from the well-intentioned restaurants, who sell good food, but feed us frozen swordfish steaks. I know. I eat them and they are good. Fresh is another level....but this .... cutting the hunk of swordfish steak from the massive fish ...that's just over the top...insanely good. My words fail me. The clams melted in my mouth. The swordfish was memorable. It came with chowder that was good and french fries and Cole slaw.I will go back to the island, with Sayle's as a definite stop. Sorry about the clam photo....I dove into them, and by the time I came to my senses long enough to stop eating, there were only a couple left, but I took a photo anyway. A fellow at the next table (there's no table service...you pay cash at the counter, and they call your name when it's ready.) The fellow had a New England Lobster Bake...oh my...steamed 1 1/4 lb lobster, steamed mussels, steamed clams, boiled red potatoes, corn on the cob with butter and broth...it was only 39. ”
“ Absolutely delicious base scallops from Nantucket lightly breaded served with tartar sauce the best I've ever had. Definitely a must to try definitely not fancy outside service available right next to the Bay. Fresh and delicious. ”
“ This is some of the best seafood we have had in the northeast. The pictures speak for themselves and we enjoyed eating on the porch overlooking the harbor. ”
“ Great place for fresh and tasty seafood! My son, who previously visited what seems to be a hidden gem, insisted we visit and it didn't disappoint! It was well worth the walk from central Nantucket. The staff was friendly and helped make the experience even better! ”